skip to content
  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Investment Q&A
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.

Investment Q&A

Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.

Q: Hello 5i,
This is pertaining to the question about moving stock In Kind from an RRSP to a TFSA. I have done this numerous times with RBC Direct Investing and I will recount the process as I have experienced it.
1. I will use 20% as the withholding tax amount as an example only. If you wish to transfer $6,500 of equity the tax is calculated as follows: 6,500 / 0.80% = 8,125 * 0.20% = $1,625 Withholding Tax.
2. The withholding tax can be either cash on hand in the account or the broker can be instructed to sell the required additional shares of the equity (or even of some other equity) to cover the cost of the tax.
3. The shares are transferred out to a cash/margin account, they do NOT go directly into the TFSA. They are then subsequently transferred into the TFSA within a day or two at the most - as I recall.
4. Make sure you retain copies of all transactions to capture all relevant data for tax purposes.
This has been my experience and the process has worked smoothly and quickly for me. And, kudos to RBC Direct Investing staff who have worked with me on doing this - they have overwhelmingly been helpful and knowledgeable.
I hope this helps......
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to all at 5i and in the 5i community!!!
Cheers,
Mike
Read Answer Asked by Mike on December 22, 2022
Q: Hi there, just reviewing YTD performance of the growth model portfolio. Net inclusion of cut previous losses(stock) through the year what is the total portfolio ytd performance? How does this year rank against previous years dating back to the inception of the growth portfolio? thx
Read Answer Asked by Chris on December 22, 2022
Q: Retired conservative investor whose only tech holding is HTA ( 5% total portfolio). Looking at either CSU or Shopify as next purchase. Which of these would you prefer to “ dip your toe “ further into the tech sector ? Also, is my weighting of HTA appropriate ? Thanks. Derek.
Read Answer Asked by Derek on December 22, 2022
Q: Tough question for sure, but disregarding other personal factors (eg, diversification etc), if you could buy 3 Cdn stocks and 3 US stocks given YOUR assessment of the investment/economic landscape, what would they be? Let's say the only parameter is performance over the next 12 months.
Read Answer Asked by Doug on December 22, 2022
Q: Peter; Just a note re Andrea’s question on in kind transfers. I just requested a in kind transfer from my RRIF to my TFSA. My broker, BMO Investor Line told me it’s not allowed- yet when I did some research it clearly is. I realize you’re not tax experts but I would appreciate your take- plus maybe ask others if they have been refused also? Thanks
Rod
Read Answer Asked by Rodney on December 22, 2022
Q: I am looking at buying some preferred shares as part of my Income Portfolio. As interest rates rise the share prices fall. When would be the opportune time to buy them, when intrest rates peak? Since markets are forward looking, when would you start buying? What would be the signal(s) to start buying? I know this is a timing question and timing is seldom perfect. Any quidance/suggestions you can offer would be greatly appreciated.
Read Answer Asked by Larry M. on December 22, 2022
Q: I hold FNV, KRR and AEM for gold exposure. I am thinking of selling FNV after the news related to their royalty stream in Panama. How material is this for FNV? Do you feel this will be an overhang on the stock in the next few months? I am hopeful for a little run in gold in the next few months and i am concerned FNV will not participate due to this news. If selling FNV, what do you recommend to compliment my other 2 holdings?
Read Answer Asked by Robert on December 22, 2022
Q: Referring to my earlier question today, would using some the tax loss sale proceeds from selling BBU to buy some more BAM violate CRA similarity rules on repurchasing?
Read Answer Asked by William Ross on December 22, 2022
Q: On the reorganization of BAMa I believe Brookfield indicated that the preliminary estimate of the cost base for taxes of BAMa would be split 88% to BN and 12% to BAM. They were to update this calculation when the transaction was completed. Do you know if there has been any update on this calculation? Thanks A Merry Christmas to All.
Mike
Read Answer Asked by Michael on December 22, 2022