skip to content
  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Investment Q&A
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.

Investment Q&A

Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.

Q: Morning 5i,
I'm light on transportation, and recently read an optimistic appraisal of MTL that considered its substantial dividend to be safe, highlighted its aggressive share buyback program (approximately $100M worth of shares last year and this) good price/cash flow and forward PE metrics and evaluated both it's business and business model as solid for the foreseeable future.
I wonder if you agree and how you would compare it to TFII which I know you like? Specifically, I'd be interested in your comparison of the two in terms of total return over three or so years.
Thanks!
Peter
Read Answer Asked by Peter on January 20, 2022
Q: Do you have a hard and fast rule for taking profits into a spike? So many stocks peaked in November and "round-tripped", many giving back their pandemic moves. I have heard -triple-sell-half, rebalance above 7%, etc. I find that they are easier said than done. Just need to add another methodology to my quiver as I have seen too many gains melt away.
Read Answer Asked by David on January 20, 2022
Q: Favorite (hammered) growth stock that pays a divy? Bit of bottom-fishing for a long term hold. Thanks Ron
Read Answer Asked by Ronald on January 20, 2022
Q: Hello Peter,
For an RESP today and future contributions with focus on Canada and USA, I was thinking of allocating more monies to indexes such as xic and xsp and less to sectors such as xfn or zeb , and xit. What are your thoughts? Also, i noticed that xsp has not done as well as SPY. i am assuming it is do to currency. In an RESP, I would think xsp on toronto and SPY on NYSE, both have withholding taxes.. Please comment. Thank you
Read Answer Asked by umedali on January 20, 2022
Q: With the business update from WELL I'm reminded of a similar update from GSY in the depths of market turmoil in 2020. I think GSY re-affirmed their business at a very low stock price ($12? maybe $20?). Had I been wiser and more knowledgeable at the time I would have bought more then and I didn't.

I'm curious why one would not add to (or start) a position in WELL today?

Thx,

Cam.
Read Answer Asked by Cameron on January 20, 2022
Q: Hi Peter/Ryan, PetroGirl and Eric Nuttlall are always arguing as to who was right and wrong about theses stocks and targets for them and the price of oil. Can you give us your unbiased opinion on these and if you wouldn't mind rating them from best to worst and which you might buy if you were interested in an oil stock. Thanks for your much valued view. Nick
Read Answer Asked by Nick on January 20, 2022
Q: I see that WELL is planning to initiate a buyback program to take advantage of the drop in share price. Are you confident in management's assessment that the share price in undervalued? The price has still more than doubled in the past two years which is a steep increase. Also debt is almost 40% of it's market cap and they aren't currently showing any earnings. How will they fund future big acquisitions to continue this growth?

If we are confident with their assessment of value and their ability to execute going forward, should we not want the share price to drop further to make the buybacks more effective? In which case, why are they releasing material to pump the share price back up?

If the answer is that they need the share price higher to help fund acquisitions by diluting shareholders then the buyback program seems misleading.
Read Answer Asked by Alex on January 20, 2022
Q: Please give me your opinion of WonderFi considering it’s recent purchase of Bitbuy.
Read Answer Asked by Jean on January 20, 2022
Q: Regarding the currency in which dividends from BAM Brookfield Asset Mgmt are paid:

I see you recently stated they pay in USD.

However on their website it says
“ Registered shareholders who are Canadian residents receive their dividends in the Cdn dollar equivalent, unless they request to receive dividends in U.S. dollars.”

So it does not seem to be based on the currency in which you buy the shares. Can you confirm?

I am waiting for my discount broker to confirm that I can receive them in USD.
Read Answer Asked by Lisa on January 20, 2022
Q: Hi 5i.
While I have never been a fan of TD Bank Locking my sister in to GIC's for her childrens' RESP, I have remained quiet on the topic.
I can no longer do that so I turn to you for some information.


For the Market linked GICs held from 2016 to 2021 - 5 years - DESPITE MARKETS and SUB Indexes being near All Time Highs, TD Bank has told my sister the maturity value of the Linked GIC is the "Minimum Guaranteed Interest Rate of 0.389% total.
Instead of the 20% Max Payout that I can easily calculate based on annual sub index values.

It is my understanding these Linked GICs are a structured product with two pieces; zero coupon Bond and a futures contract. If Markets are at all time highs (annual index values below) how can TD Bank claim the product meets only the minimum interest payment? Do you have any insight into these products or know of a resource. The reason we are in the dark is due to the Financial Planner at TD saying, "sorry I can't help you understand that, it is calculated at head office".
(side note: I wonder if this Planner will be able to sell this product after the March Know Your Client changes? The TD Product is obviously not known to the Branch Planners)


The GIC - 50/50 link to TSX Bank Index and TSX Utility Index


Bank Index Values(Jan 3, 2017 thru Dec 31 2021:
3169.62, 3467.88, 3067.94, 3398.64, 3326.3, 4418.27
Utility Index Values ( Jan 3, 2017 thru Dec 31, 2921)
235.05, 250.41, 216.78, 290.84, 319.5, 343.21


Are these products just a TD Bank Scam and will never pay out?
How can the Markets be at all time highs, after a massive run from March 2009, and this TD Bank Market Linked GIC ONLY payout "Minimum Guaranteed Interest of 0.389%?

What are the steps to make TD Bank prove this outcome?
At Branch level they claim ignorance.

PS.....Unfortunately it does not only pertain to this year. Now I have to go back to each of the past three years to see if only minimum interest was paid instead of my calculated max Payout.
Read Answer Asked by Dave on January 20, 2022
Q: With technology stocks presently going out of favour with buyers what 5 Canadian and 5 US technology stocks would i5Research recommend for a long time hold in a TFSA. Thanks … Cal
Read Answer Asked by cal on January 20, 2022
Looking for more? Sign up for a FREE 14 day trial! No credit card required

We invite you to sign up for a 14 day free trial of 5i Research!
Experience all the benefits and tools we have to offer; stock research, model portfolios, Q&A with our experts, and so much more. Join a community of like-minded investors today!