skip to content
  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Investment Q&A
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.

Investment Q&A

Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.

Q: In one answer to someone's question, you rated CAR.UN a sell. I have a full position in a TFSA as a long term hold and am down 18%. Should I continue to own, add more as it goes down, or sell. What is the health of this company especially if inflation/stagflation and interest rates get worse going forward. What is your 5 year outlook on this name? Thanks!
Read Answer Asked by Pat on May 14, 2026
Q: I did not expect this REIT to reach such a low price, since I did not find news or results that would justifie this " nonstop" sliding .At a 25% loss on paper , I wish to sell this REIT if there were significant longer term risks , even at this very low valuation (in order to use the loss vs capital gains ), but I would keep this REIT if it was "still" considered as a solid Cie financially with safe dividends . Could you please weight "pros and cons" in this context ..
Read Answer Asked by Jean-Yves on May 14, 2026
Q: Hello,
I own both CAR.UN and DIR.UN, am growing tired of watching CAR's share price steadily decline over the past 5 years.
Could you suggest a replacement for CAR.UN with a better growth profile, decent yield, not necessarily residential?
Thanks as always.
Read Answer Asked by Roman on April 20, 2026
Q: Hello 5i, I am a current unit holder of ERE.UN and would like you to comment on the latest news release as to the current shareowners are being offered.
Are there options for cash or shares of CAR.UN and what are the chances of another
bid for the company.
Read Answer Asked by Michael on March 04, 2026
Q: Hi Again. Similar to my last question, with consolidation in mind, would you please rank the above holdings in order of "sell" to "keep".

Carl
Read Answer Asked by Carl on March 02, 2026
Q: Hi 5I. I would like to consolidate this mixed bag into one or two holdings. Would you please rank them in order of "sell" to "keep".

Carl
Read Answer Asked by Carl on February 27, 2026
Q: Hi, Sorry there are lot of companies listed but in summary this is three part question:

1. I have BAM2%,BN9%,BEP5%. I was thinking of putting new money to KKR or BX or APO. Should i add new money to existing positions or to new positions. Which one and approx. price please.

2. All the listed are in red in various taxable and registered accounts. Which one is good candidate for new money , which one would be sell and hold.

3. ISRG is at 1.5%. Should i go to 5% in one shot or go slowly or just hold on . This is in taxable account.

Thanks
Read Answer Asked by S on February 05, 2026
Q: Questions on CAR.UN:

- Is the negative opinion regarding the recent immigration policy overblown?

- How does present valuation compare to it's historical past per the appropriate metrics?

- Are there major risks if / when there is a severe economic downturn?

- Can you comment on its balance sheet?

- Do you see its plan for modernizing its portfolio as impactful to the business?

- Are you optimistic about its ability to keep increasing distributions going forward?
Read Answer Asked by James on January 15, 2026
Q: As I do my year-end review, I am always looking for moves that can add potential ZIP for next year while being mindful of my senior years (old). My portfolio is well established in weighting and sectoral positioning. Chp.un has been in it since 2020 and has given me a 16% return (x div). It seems to have a muted outlook for 2026. What is your view on a switch to the somewhat out-of-favour car.un. At $37.80 ish and estimated up to $48 range next year, it seems like a solid move for growth potential. Not too worried about the minor div variance here. As always thank you for your service.
Read Answer Asked by James on December 01, 2025
Q: Reviewing recent questions on these coys Considering tax loss sale of car.un and replacing it with more supposedly growthy fsv. Alternatively could add more dir.un which is a keeper for me now. Other name's also in total portfolio but only bn is a keeper. Your views?
Read Answer Asked by William Ross on November 21, 2025
Q: Hello,
I have owned CAR.UN & DIR.UN for a number years and would like to sell one and keep the other for a long-term income hold.
Which would you keep?
Thanks as always.
Read Answer Asked by Roman on November 18, 2025
Q: Hi, I own the companies mentioned above. Companies on unregistered account have been beaten down, what order would you sell them in or should some be held?

Thank you
Read Answer Asked by jovan on October 31, 2025
Q: Understandably Real Estate cos. are not prominent in the minds of investors these days and in Canada they are under alot of pressure but am wondering if CAR.UN is a screaming BUY for one who is willing to wait through a couple more years of AI craze?

It shows CAR.UN book Value at $56.00 per share whilst price today is $39.00. Am already a holder of Minto which i earlier saw Book Value of $29.00 but yr site shows a P/B value of 1.06 so not sure about that number.

These companies may carry alot of debt but wondering yr thoughts on the opportunity here on these reits and the relative risks of each as a 3 year investment?
Read Answer Asked by Craig on October 31, 2025
Q: Hi Peter,
I have CAR.UN in my RRSP account for a number of years. It has performed poorly for the past year, though interest rate is heading downward which should be good for REITs. What are the reasons, apart from immigration restriction, for the negative momentum for CAR.UN? I’ve a 13% loss on this stock and I am thinking of selling it with no tax loss benefit and buy another REIT. Please suggest a few REITs that will provide a stable dividend and flourish in this economy. I’m thinking NWH.UN can be one possibility but it is at a year high. I already owned DIR.UN, BEI.UN and PLZ.UN. Thanks.
Read Answer Asked by Willie on October 30, 2025
Q: My portfolio is income based. I have capital losses in BCE, CAR,UN and ENGH. What order would you sell them in or should some be held? I am looking to replace some or all with the following; BIP.UN, NWC.UN and/or RCI.B. How would you rank them for acquisition?
Read Answer Asked by David on October 27, 2025
Q: Each of these have fallen below 1% percent of total portfolio value in my non-reg account. What order of preference would you suggest for adding to top up? Altrnatively should any go or should there be a new addition? I am low in consumer cycles, comms and health.
Read Answer Asked by William Ross on October 08, 2025
Looking for more? Sign up for a FREE 14 day trial! No credit card required

We invite you to sign up for a 14 day free trial of 5i Research!
Experience all the benefits and tools we have to offer; stock research, model portfolios, Q&A with our experts, and so much more. Join a community of like-minded investors today!