Q: Where do you think Canadian Railroad Stocks are going, and do you have a favorite?
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.
Investment Q&A
Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.
Q: Hi folks,
CP or CNR - I currently have both - CNR in my TFSA and CP in non-registered account . Would you sell CNR or CP at this time and why ? Thinking about buying more CP now that they have announced the split.
Thanks
CP or CNR - I currently have both - CNR in my TFSA and CP in non-registered account . Would you sell CNR or CP at this time and why ? Thinking about buying more CP now that they have announced the split.
Thanks
- Canadian National Railway Company (CNR)
- Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited (CP)
- Air Canada Voting and Variable Voting Shares (AC)
- Kinaxis Inc. (KXS)
- Barrick Gold Corporation (ABX)
- Real Matters Inc. (REAL)
- WELL Health Technologies Corp. (WELL)
- Lightspeed Commerce Inc. Subordinate Voting Shares (LSPD)
- Nuvei Corporation Subordinate Voting Shares (NVEI)
Q: Hi 5i,
First of all, thanks for your advise to help me understand more for the US & Canadian stock markets. I have a feeling that the US market will end the over 10 years bull market soon and bear market will come in. Due to the issue of GME, BB, NOK, and AMC showing many "NEW" investors involve the US and Canadian market (because of the BB), specially the Reddit social media investor forums is not healthy. I guess the Canadian market may also affected, due to the BB issue. Just in case the bear market will come, what the above stocks need to be sold to play safe. I am thinking to sell KXS, LSPD, and NVEI, those stock prices may not be survival during the big drop in coming. Do you have the same feeling that the bear market will come? Can you please rank the above stocks able to survival during the bear market and please suggest to take off any just in case the worst worst things really happen.
First of all, thanks for your advise to help me understand more for the US & Canadian stock markets. I have a feeling that the US market will end the over 10 years bull market soon and bear market will come in. Due to the issue of GME, BB, NOK, and AMC showing many "NEW" investors involve the US and Canadian market (because of the BB), specially the Reddit social media investor forums is not healthy. I guess the Canadian market may also affected, due to the BB issue. Just in case the bear market will come, what the above stocks need to be sold to play safe. I am thinking to sell KXS, LSPD, and NVEI, those stock prices may not be survival during the big drop in coming. Do you have the same feeling that the bear market will come? Can you please rank the above stocks able to survival during the bear market and please suggest to take off any just in case the worst worst things really happen.
- Canadian National Railway Company (CNR)
- Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited (CP)
- Air Canada Voting and Variable Voting Shares (AC)
- TFI International Inc. (TFII)
Q: My portfolio doesn't have any coverage in the transportation sector. What stocks/etf's would you recommend in this area.
Rick
Rick
- Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited (CP)
- Sun Life Financial Inc. (SLF)
- BRP Inc. Subordinate Voting Shares (DOO)
- Kinaxis Inc. (KXS)
- goeasy Ltd. (GSY)
Q: My 18-year-old daughter is interested in the stock market and wants to understand the value of owning stocks. She is looking to follow 6 stocks. She has some post-secondary aspirations for next year and would like your suggestions on 3 stable and 3 growth-oriented companies that you would buy today. Thanks
Q: What are your thoughts between these two?
Robert
Robert
- Costco Wholesale Corporation (COST)
- Alphabet Inc. (GOOG)
- Microsoft Corporation (MSFT)
- Starbucks Corporation (SBUX)
- Lockheed Martin Corporation (LMT)
- Enbridge Inc. (ENB)
- Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited (CP)
- Kinaxis Inc. (KXS)
- Thomson Reuters Corporation (TRI)
Q: My parents (late 70's) will be receiving proceeds from the sale of a US asset and are looking to add to their existing investment portfolio (an additional 25%) . They are financially stable with a long term balanced portfolio and are interested in allocating the new cash into quality, long term positions with growth potential. US, Canada and industry non specific. What would you recommend as your top 5 US and Canadian positions and why?
- Chevron Corporation (CVX)
- Union Pacific Corporation (UNP)
- Canadian National Railway Company (CNR)
- Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited (CP)
Q: Hi,
What do you think generally about the railroads for a long term hold? If you like them, plse suggest one CDN and one US
What do you think generally about the railroads for a long term hold? If you like them, plse suggest one CDN and one US
Q: Why are Cn and Cp down today while Union Paciic a U.S railway and markets are up?
Q: Good morning,
Wondering if you could shed some light on the decline in CP shares this morning ?
Thank you
Wondering if you could shed some light on the decline in CP shares this morning ?
Thank you
- Toronto-Dominion Bank (The) (TD)
- Bank of Nova Scotia (The) (BNS)
- Canadian National Railway Company (CNR)
- BCE Inc. (BCE)
- Enbridge Inc. (ENB)
- Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited (CP)
- TMX Group Limited (X)
- Brookfield Renewable Corporation Class A Exchangeable Subordinate Voting Shares (BEPC)
Q: You have referred to some stocks and ETFs as CORE. What percentage of portfolio would you recommend as core (relative to satellite holdings) and what would be the number of core stocks and ETFs for diversification. What core stocks and ETFs across all sectors would you recommend?.
- Royal Bank of Canada (RY)
- Canadian National Railway Company (CNR)
- Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited (CP)
- Constellation Software Inc. (CSU)
- Toromont Industries Ltd. (TIH)
- RB Global Inc. (RBA)
- Thomson Reuters Corporation (TRI)
Q: 7:18 AM 10/7/2020
I am having a lot of difficulty trying to calculate or find Compound Annual Growth Rates [CAGR] of share prices without [and with] dividends reinvested. Do you know opf a reliable source?
Sources tend to differ a lot perhaps because of not properly accounting for share price stock splits.
I would appreciate it if you could give me CAGRs without and with dividends reinvested for
CNR, CP, TIH, RBA, TRI, BAM.A, RY, CSU.
Thank you......... Paul K.
I am having a lot of difficulty trying to calculate or find Compound Annual Growth Rates [CAGR] of share prices without [and with] dividends reinvested. Do you know opf a reliable source?
Sources tend to differ a lot perhaps because of not properly accounting for share price stock splits.
I would appreciate it if you could give me CAGRs without and with dividends reinvested for
CNR, CP, TIH, RBA, TRI, BAM.A, RY, CSU.
Thank you......... Paul K.
- Toronto-Dominion Bank (The) (TD)
- Manulife Financial Corporation (MFC)
- TC Energy Corporation (TRP)
- Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited (CP)
- CGI Inc. Class A Subordinate Voting Shares (GIB.A)
- Fortis Inc. (FTS)
- Restaurant Brands International Inc. (QSR)
- Shopify Inc. Class A Subordinate Voting Shares (SHOP)
Q: Dear 5i team:
Your software indicates our family’s investments are too Canadian-focused. However, I prefer our “home bias”, for three reasons:
(a) most of our assets are non-registered, and the dividend tax credit is especially favourable for Canadian source dividends in a province such as ours (Ontario);
(b) I like supporting the companies that I invest in (e.g., we buy Peller family wines, since we own their shares);
(c) but most important, many of the “Canadian” businesses we own are surprisingly international; among our top 20 equity holdings are:
Alimentation couche-tarde (Circle K is world-wide);
Brookfield Asset Management (globally focused company that invests wherever the opportunities are);
CGI Group (revenues are 84% outside Canada per 2019 annual report);
CP Rail (significant U.S. revenues);
Fortis (65% of earning are in U.S.);
Manulife (growing Asian revenues);
Restaurant Brands International (most of Burger King and Popeye’s restaurants are outside of Canada);
Shopify (not sure, but suspect international revenues are growing faster than Canadian revenues);
TC Energy (dropped “Canada” from its name to reflect its growing U.S. presence);
TD bank (substantial and growing U.S. presence);
Anyways, the above-listed 10 stocks represent about one-third of our overall equity holdings (in absolute $ terms), but I would not consider these companies as being “100% Canadian”. I wonder whether your software could be rejigged to reflect the relative percent earnings (or revenue) contributions, broken down per Canada, U.S., Europe, Asia, and so forth. I suspect our home “bias” is not nearly as substantial as it appears.
Ted
Your software indicates our family’s investments are too Canadian-focused. However, I prefer our “home bias”, for three reasons:
(a) most of our assets are non-registered, and the dividend tax credit is especially favourable for Canadian source dividends in a province such as ours (Ontario);
(b) I like supporting the companies that I invest in (e.g., we buy Peller family wines, since we own their shares);
(c) but most important, many of the “Canadian” businesses we own are surprisingly international; among our top 20 equity holdings are:
Alimentation couche-tarde (Circle K is world-wide);
Brookfield Asset Management (globally focused company that invests wherever the opportunities are);
CGI Group (revenues are 84% outside Canada per 2019 annual report);
CP Rail (significant U.S. revenues);
Fortis (65% of earning are in U.S.);
Manulife (growing Asian revenues);
Restaurant Brands International (most of Burger King and Popeye’s restaurants are outside of Canada);
Shopify (not sure, but suspect international revenues are growing faster than Canadian revenues);
TC Energy (dropped “Canada” from its name to reflect its growing U.S. presence);
TD bank (substantial and growing U.S. presence);
Anyways, the above-listed 10 stocks represent about one-third of our overall equity holdings (in absolute $ terms), but I would not consider these companies as being “100% Canadian”. I wonder whether your software could be rejigged to reflect the relative percent earnings (or revenue) contributions, broken down per Canada, U.S., Europe, Asia, and so forth. I suspect our home “bias” is not nearly as substantial as it appears.
Ted
Q: I'm looking to start a new position in one of the above. They are both trading very close to each other in valuation. CN is bigger with more reach so I was leaning that way but wanted your take. Why would you go with one over the other? This would be in my TFSA.
(I feel like I have enough spicy growth names in my TFSA and am looking for something I can let sit for 20 years and not think about.)
Thanks
(I feel like I have enough spicy growth names in my TFSA and am looking for something I can let sit for 20 years and not think about.)
Thanks
- United Parcel Service Inc. (UPS)
- Canadian National Railway Company (CNR)
- Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited (CP)
- TFI International Inc. (TFII)
Q: Hi guys,
Wondering your thoughts on truck based shippers like tfi and ups as compared to railways? With a 5+ year time horizon, what has a likely higher rate of return overall and success probability with the economy ahead?
Thoughts on whether to invest now at all versus waiting 1 to 3 months for more earning to sink in?
Thanks
Peter
Wondering your thoughts on truck based shippers like tfi and ups as compared to railways? With a 5+ year time horizon, what has a likely higher rate of return overall and success probability with the economy ahead?
Thoughts on whether to invest now at all versus waiting 1 to 3 months for more earning to sink in?
Thanks
Peter
- Canadian Pacific Kansas City Limited (CP)
- Tricon Residential Inc. (TCN)
- iShares S&P/TSX Capped Energy Index ETF (XEG)
- Nutrien Ltd. (NTR)
Q: I carry these stocks in my RIF account with different level of loss. They do not seems to respond to any positive move in the market. I am loosing patience. Should I sell.
What replacements would you recommend that could recover faster in this type of market.
I value as usual your opinion
Raouf
What replacements would you recommend that could recover faster in this type of market.
I value as usual your opinion
Raouf
Q: Hi guys,
I hold CP in my portfolio at 3% (still in the green), thinking about switching to L or Costco for a little more security in these difficult times, your thoughts?
Keep safe,
Jim
I hold CP in my portfolio at 3% (still in the green), thinking about switching to L or Costco for a little more security in these difficult times, your thoughts?
Keep safe,
Jim
Q: After reading your special report and market update today, I'm curious if you would also be looking at CN or CP following lots of volatility for them. Would this be an opportunity? and would one of them look more attractive to you than the other?
Q: Hello,
Your thoughts on CP rail, I am copying your balance portfolio and wonder if CP would be a fit for my portfolio.
thanks,
Jim
Your thoughts on CP rail, I am copying your balance portfolio and wonder if CP would be a fit for my portfolio.
thanks,
Jim
Q: I have a substantial amount of CN shares. Would it be prudent to exchange my cn shares for cp rail shares. In my opinion, the Ceo of CNR (Ruest) has done a terrible job of managing CN Rail. The 6 month performance of CN is -3.5% while the market has been on a tear. While CP is up over 4.5% in the same time period. Not sure how much business CN has given up with the strike either.