Investment Q&A

Q: Would you comment on the relative minvestmetn merit of our two large railways with or without a successful merger of CP with KC?

Q: If commodities continue to rally would you see the rails as a good lower risk proxy for the sector. Which of the two rails is cheaper on valuation.

Thanks

Q: Looking to add a transport for my industrials sector exposure. I have a bit of cargojet. I'm about breakeven. With the recent pullback, thinking of high grading and dumping cargojet for CNR or TFII. Wise decision? If so, which do you prefer?

Thanks!
Jason

Q: Based on Keystone XL decision, more crude will most likely be shipped by rail. US refineries need Canadian crude oil caused by shortfall from South America. Gibson plans to build facility to maximize crude content of rail shipments.
With footprint of tracks being different, who stands to benefit the most and why?

Q: Looking for a transportation play. These are the 3 that come to mind. 1) Am I too late to get in for economy opening play 2) which would be highest growth potential 3) is there a disruptor or smaller more leveraged play that you can suggest.

Q: Where do you think Canadian Railroad Stocks are going, and do you have a favorite?

Q: Hi,
Your opinion on GIB.A, CNR, LAC and FB Please.
Thank you.

Q: Bill Gates sold $370,000,000 worth of CNR shares recently. Are there any negative developments in your view with respect to this company? As well, I noted that two brokers have lowered their targets from $165 to $160 and from $155 to $139 respectively.
I will appreciate your comments with respect to CNR going forward. Is it a hold, sell or add to existing position?
Thanks

Q: Hi folks,
CP or CNR - I currently have both - CNR in my TFSA and CP in non-registered account . Would you sell CNR or CP at this time and why ? Thinking about buying more CP now that they have announced the split.
Thanks

Q: Hello -
I have a concern about the grossing up of Canadian dividends (non registered account) affecting my OAS when I reach 71. By that time I will be forced to RRIF, I'll have my CPP, and I also have a company pension that I will be drawing from prior to that.

I know you are not tax experts, but wondered if you see anything wrong with my thinking here. I am leaning more towards lower paying dividend paying blue chips in that non-registered account. I already have ATD.B and CNR. Are there any other quality Canadian companies that you are comfortable with in this "lower dividend" category?

Alternatively I was thinking I could "swap" some investments. i.e. have more Canadian dividend payers in my RRSP and have my emerging market ETF's - ZID and VEE - in my non-registered account. Do you think this is worth considering?
At least those dividends would not be grossed up. Although the trade-off is that you lose the dividend credit.......sigh.

Q: Hi 5i,

First of all, thanks for your advise to help me understand more for the US & Canadian stock markets. I have a feeling that the US market will end the over 10 years bull market soon and bear market will come in. Due to the issue of GME, BB, NOK, and AMC showing many "NEW" investors involve the US and Canadian market (because of the BB), specially the Reddit social media investor forums is not healthy. I guess the Canadian market may also affected, due to the BB issue. Just in case the bear market will come, what the above stocks need to be sold to play safe. I am thinking to sell KXS, LSPD, and NVEI, those stock prices may not be survival during the big drop in coming. Do you have the same feeling that the bear market will come? Can you please rank the above stocks able to survival during the bear market and please suggest to take off any just in case the worst worst things really happen.

Q: I am looking to rebalance my non-registered portfolio, which will mean taking capital gains and transfer to my TFSA. Today, my position is about equal in RY, BMO and CNR.
I would like to reinvest the cash from these capital gains in Tech and Health sectors from 5i's balanced portfolio. I do not have either sector in my TFSA today.
Which of the 3 non-registered stocks would you suggest selling?
What would you recommend buying for TFSA?

Q: My portfolio doesn't have any coverage in the transportation sector. What stocks/etf's would you recommend in this area.

Rick

Q: I am trying to clean up our RIF, TFSA, and cash accounts. I believe that 5i has suggested that capital gain stocks are best in the TFSA. A RIF should not have dividend stocks, they should be in the non registered account.
I want to move in kind BCE from a TFSA account to our non registered account in December. In January I want to move BCE, CN, and RY out of a RIF. This would be the 2021 withdrawal from the RIF. These would be moved in kind from the RIF into the non-registered account. CN would be moved same day to theTFSA in January as a part of the contribution for 2021.

I thought I had sent the same question on Sunday night but I have not had a response yet so I’m assuming that it was lost somewhere. Hopefully I have not confused you and I have given you the picture. My question primarily is your thoughts on the general idea of what I have proposed. The CN stock is being put in to the TFSA because it will be more of a growth stock and the dividend is smaller.

Also where would you suggest a US stock be held? We have one or two growth stocks like SQ, no dividend, that we would like to put into the TFSA. Is that appropriate?

Thanks again for all that 5i does. Much appreciated.
John

Q: Hi Team, I own a full position in Union Pacific railway in the U.S. But I have some cash to place in a solid Canadian company for a 3-5 year period. Would you support CNR for this? Or would you suggest that with UNP already owned, there are other Cdn names to favour over CNR? Thanks!

Q: What are your thoughts between these two?

Robert

Q: Hi,

What do you think generally about the railroads for a long term hold? If you like them, plse suggest one CDN and one US

Q: I bought CN rail shares at ~$115 so I’m happy but it seems like CP may have been a better choice. Which is your preference going forward please?

Q: Why are Cn and Cp down today while Union Paciic a U.S railway and markets are up?

Q: ARK Invest recently produced a Bad Ideas Report for 2020.
The one that particularly caught my attention was on railroads. Their thesis is that the trend in place since early 2000's in which rail had been taking share from trucking will reverse with the commercialization of autonomous electric trucks.
They believe that during the next five years autonomous electric trucks will provide faster and more convenient door to door service , increase productivity , lower costs dramatically and take share from rail.
While their projections may be aggressive , they have a pretty good record at identifying disruptive trends. And , as someone who has owned CNR for over a decade and always considered it a forever hold , this caught my attention.
Would appreciate your thoughts .
Thank-you.