skip to content
  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Investment Q&A
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.

Investment Q&A

Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.

Q: Hi Peter and Team,

The other question I have is with regards to a previous answered question, where you mentioned across a RRSP, Investment and TFSA, the recommended breakdown is 6 stocks in the RRSP, 6 in the investment and 8 in the TFSA.

Since my RRSP holds 85% of my capital, would it be better to weigh the stocks as 12 stocks in the RRSP, 4 each in the Investment/TFSA, or is it better to follow the breakdown of 6/6/8?

Thanks again for the great work you do.

Read Answer Asked by Marvin on March 21, 2017
Q: I'm trying to tidy up my wife's RRSP small holdings, of the currently 26 in total.
ECM @ .65% [of the total portfolio] up 14.65%
EFX @ 1.26% " up 43.66%
SIS @ 1.49% " up 2.65%
TIO @ 1.35 " up 44% [taken out by PP,decision made]
I was considering consolidating these 4 to just one or two names.
Your thoughts on this action and or alternate suggestions?

Cheers and thx for your fine service!
Read Answer Asked by Henry on February 21, 2017
Q: RRSP question: Assume I am an Alberta resident with $0 income in 2017. How much can I withdraw from from my RRSP account while maintaining a 0% tax rate (disregard withholding tax)? 2017 Basic Alberta Personal Amount is $18,690 at 10% and Federal amount is $11,635 at 15%. And, can I make this withdrawal now (Feb. 17) for 2017 or does the March 1st RRSP cutoff date apply for withdrawals as well? Thanks.
Read Answer Asked by Curtis on February 21, 2017
Q: Regarding Bill's RRSP transfer to Questrade from a brokerage, the main issue of selling the investments to reinvest the funds is the tax implication. The sold RRSPs would be taxed, likely at 25%, and depending upon his RRSP contribution limit, he might not be able to reinvest the net sum. The RRSP amount would be included in his taxable income for the year of withdrawal and if large enough would "bump" him into a higher tax bracket. He would pay tax on the withdrawal at his marginal rate.

As you suggested, the transfer in kind is the only way to make this transfer without incurring any tax.
Read Answer Asked by Michael on February 13, 2017
Q: I am just about to set up my portfolio. I am following your balanced equity portfolio. Most will be put into TFSA. I have to select about 6 to go in non registered. Obviously these would be the ones I would expect lower returns. Which ones should I select? I plan to keep not touch these investments for 8 years.
T Steve
Read Answer Asked by Stephen on January 30, 2017
Q: thank you for reading my email - and for your assistance.
I have these above stocks in an rrsp, - can you suggest - how I can diversify
Read Answer Asked by Marla on January 11, 2017
Q: Hello 5i team,
I think it is time for my wife to redeploy her cash position in the combined RRSP and TFSA portfolios.
I’m listing below her current holdings by the various TSX sectors, by weight and my proposed choice of additions. I would appreciate your opinion as to your order of preference at this time.
Consumer cyclicals (11%) CGX, MG; propose CCL, BYD or TOY
Consumer defensives (0%); propose ATD, DOL or PBH
Energy (8%) ENB, KEY: propose a producer
Financials (13%) SLF, TD; propose any addition?
Health (6%) ZUH; propose any addition?
Industrials (7%) BIP.UN; propose CNR, SIS, STN, WSP
Materials (0%); propose MX or SJ
Info tech (13%) CSU, GIB; propose ENGH, KXS or SYZ
RE/Telcos/Utilities (15%) BCE, BEP.UN, CIGI, FSC; propose reduce BCE or sell CIGI
Cash (26%)
I would not mind that you deduct any number of credits.
Thanks,
Antoine
Read Answer Asked by Antoine on December 12, 2016
Q: Good afternoon,

My question pertains to holding US equities in various accounts. Can you please validate or refute the following:

Cash account: US dividends are taxed as interest-50%, and a 15% withholding tax is applied which can be redeemed during tax season.

RRSP: US equities are supposed to be capital gains and divends tax free. However, I have noticed that some equities, such as limited partnerships have their dividend taxed at 38% with an additional 15 % non redeemable withholding tax. Can you confirm this, and are their any other types of US equities that are Exempt from RRSP tax sheltering?

I have also been told that US equity ETFs that are listed in the US are also have their dividends taxed. Is this true? And would this be the same for US equity ETFs that are listed in Canada (ex: those listed on black rock Canada website )?

Thank you for bringing some clarity to the issue. Any other tips you may have would be well appreciated.

Cheers,

KR
Read Answer Asked by Karim on November 28, 2016
Q: Managing my wife's RRSP. She is 30 years old, but a somewhat conservative investor. I have a position in TD, SLF, NFI after recent pullback ($38), SJ ($42) and BEI ($50). I am looking for another stock to add. With limited funds, it is hard to diversify across all sectors. What stock would you suggest?

Thanks,
Jason
Read Answer Asked by Jason on November 11, 2016
Q: RRIF - I have to convert my RRSP to a RIF by the end of the year. My broker is TDW. TD Canada Trust, their agent, wants me to make the minimum withdrawal on a regular schedule ie monthly, quarterly etc.
I want to make the withdrawals on an as required basis, subject to the annual minimum, to help with my overall cash flow demands.
Is there a legal requirement to do it TD's way?
Thanks
Read Answer Asked by David on October 17, 2016
Looking for more? Sign up for a FREE 14 day trial! No credit card required

We invite you to sign up for a 14 day free trial of 5i Research!
Experience all the benefits and tools we have to offer; stock research, model portfolios, Q&A with our experts, and so much more. Join a community of like-minded investors today!