skip to content
  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Investment Q&A
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.

Investment Q&A

Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.

Q: Good morning

What is ATD's average Historical P/E ratio, say for the past 5 or 10 years?

What is the High and Low Historical P/E ratio, the range, during that time period?

Dividing ATD's current stock price of $69 by their reported net income per share of $2.72 yields a Historical P/E ratio of 25.4.

Am I doing what seems like a simple calculation correctly?

I ask because I am seeing a Future P/E ratio for ATD in the financial press of 17.3, which implies a large increase in net income compared with their last fiscal year, a decline in stock price, or some combination of the two,

How should one interpret this dramatic change in Future vs Historical P/E for ATD?

And finally, what is 5i's view on how expensive ATD's price is currently, compared with past history? Does 5i support accumulating ATD shares at this point?

Thank you.

Edward

Read Answer Asked by Edward on July 15, 2025
Q: Are there some utility or resource companies that will especially benefit from the need for increased electricity for data centres for AI and crypto?
Read Answer Asked by Maria on July 14, 2025
Q: 1) For these listed firms, which ones have the strongest link to the nuclear energy field?
2) I have a fair sized holding in WSP but am eager to branch out for diversification purposes to either STN or ATRL. I see from other questions, 5i's seems to favour STN as a compliment to WSP. How strong is STN in the nuclear field (their website suggests some capability)?
With thanks.
Read Answer Asked by David C. on July 10, 2025
Q: what is the annualized return of SPY, QQQ and XIC over the last 20 years. I thought I read an answer where you said the S&P only was 2% including dividends which seems too low.
Read Answer Asked by Cheryl on July 10, 2025
Q: What is vertically managed software VMS and what would be admission criteria and what would not.
Read Answer Asked by ANDREW on July 10, 2025
Q: I would like to start a position in the crypto/blockchain space of approximately 5% in my portfolio. How do you best envision me achieving this goal?
Read Answer Asked by philip on July 10, 2025
Q: ETF's|: India, Lat. America, Health Reit's
tks H.
Read Answer Asked by Adelheid on July 10, 2025
Q: Hello
Is it possible to receive from you the compound average growth rate of tax 60, SP500 and Canadian aggregate bond market with inception date of dec 31, 2012? (12.5 years)
Read Answer Asked by David on July 08, 2025
Q: How would you rank the following for purchasing today? Are there any you would not purchase or would only purchase a portion of final holding?
Read Answer Asked by David on July 08, 2025
Q: I have all three of these positions.

I'm happy to keep my capital invested in the Brookfield empire, but it feels inefficient and not thought out the way it sits in my portfolio, almost like a series of afterthoughts.

The breakdown of the three (as a % of their cumulative totals in my portfolio)

BN = 57%
BEPC = 8%
BEP.UN = 35%

(Ignoring the whole tax schmozzle with reg vs NR accounts),

Would you recommend any changes? That could include adding another Brookfield entity as a possibility.
Read Answer Asked by Robert on July 08, 2025
Q: Now that Canada is ratcheting up defense spending, I am looking to invest in this sector. Here are a few aerospace defence companies I know of CAE, Magellan, MDA, Bombardier.
Would any of these stocks have potential for growth.
Would you have any other suggestions.
Thank you.
Rick and Chris Fralick.
Read Answer Asked by Rick and Chris on July 07, 2025