Q: Just a comment to Edward re: CDN/US citizenship - the US treats a TFSA as just another account, and all income is taxable by the IRS, even though exempt by the CRA. Not sure there is any reason for a US citizen to hold a TFSA. If there is any advantage to a TFSA under these circumstances, I would appreciate hearing it.
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.
Investment Q&A
Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.
Q: I was disturbed by Bruce's question re US citizens owning 'foreign' stocks. My wife and I are both dual Candian/US citizens and we live in Canada. We own 100% Canadian dividend stocks in a joint portfolio, two TFSAs and a RIF. We will not buy US stocks as the IRS takes 20% of the dividend right off the top while the Canadian tax man gives us a break on dividends. Do you know of any problems we might face, other than paying our accountant about $1700 a year to fill out our ridiculously complicated income tax returns?
Q: Do you have any market intelligence on a potential market pull back?
Are there any known upcoming events that would escalate a pull back?
If and when a pull back occurs, what percentage will the markets drop? I know you don't have a crystal ball, just looking for your gut feel/market instincts.
Thanks!
Are there any known upcoming events that would escalate a pull back?
If and when a pull back occurs, what percentage will the markets drop? I know you don't have a crystal ball, just looking for your gut feel/market instincts.
Thanks!
Q: Because of recent tax rules, US citizens are restricted in the amount of money they can keep in other countries unless they have $$$ to pay international tax accountants.
Neither can they cost effectively own ETFs, REITS, trusts, mutual funds, etc.--again due to arcane rules and draconian penalties for non-compliance.
Therefore, I can buy only a small number of stocks in Canada, and I would hope to hold them for long periods for fewer tax reporting complications from buying and selling.
Would you see enough potential, without overdoing risk, for a portfolio of such stocks, totaling no more than 120k to purchase? Could a yield of 3 to 5% be achievable?
On top of all this, there is no telling when new rules may be composed that make owning ANY stocks in Canada prohibitive, so I have to be prepared to sell whenever they make such a change. For example, we had to sell our TFSAs and ETFs swiftly upon being alerted to the current restrictions.
Thank you for any response.
Neither can they cost effectively own ETFs, REITS, trusts, mutual funds, etc.--again due to arcane rules and draconian penalties for non-compliance.
Therefore, I can buy only a small number of stocks in Canada, and I would hope to hold them for long periods for fewer tax reporting complications from buying and selling.
Would you see enough potential, without overdoing risk, for a portfolio of such stocks, totaling no more than 120k to purchase? Could a yield of 3 to 5% be achievable?
On top of all this, there is no telling when new rules may be composed that make owning ANY stocks in Canada prohibitive, so I have to be prepared to sell whenever they make such a change. For example, we had to sell our TFSAs and ETFs swiftly upon being alerted to the current restrictions.
Thank you for any response.
Q: What are your criteria when you consider a stock is expensive versus cheap?
- Or do you compare the company P/E to its industry peers (i.e.: Financials, Tech, Consumer Staples, Oil/Gas, etc.)?
- Or do you compare the company P/E ratio to the company growth rate (Revenue, Earnings/share, Cash flow) from the previous year's quarter?
- Or something else?
Thank you.
- Or do you compare the company P/E to its industry peers (i.e.: Financials, Tech, Consumer Staples, Oil/Gas, etc.)?
- Or do you compare the company P/E ratio to the company growth rate (Revenue, Earnings/share, Cash flow) from the previous year's quarter?
- Or something else?
Thank you.
Q: Hello 5i,
Would a LIRA account have the same general tax rules as a RRSP (especially with regard to the dividend tax credit and withholding tax on US dividend) ? Based on my research it appears to be the case but I was looking for confirmation. Any advice or comments would be appreciated. Thank you.
Would a LIRA account have the same general tax rules as a RRSP (especially with regard to the dividend tax credit and withholding tax on US dividend) ? Based on my research it appears to be the case but I was looking for confirmation. Any advice or comments would be appreciated. Thank you.
Q: Is BITCOIN the new gold ? What is the best way to invest in it ?
Q: Since 2007 my wife and I have contributed our best appreciated securities in our cash account to a Private Giving Foundation (PGF) at TDWaterhouse which has helped us minimize income tax by escaping the capital gains tax thus maximizing charitable donations. For the earlier contributions, once in the PGF the money from stock sales has been invested in the TD Balanced Income Fund which has had stodgy performance and steep MER, and TD Monthly Income Fund lately which is sort of ok for both. We have no choice in the allocation of investments once our securities have been committed to the PGF.
For our future contributions to a PGF are you aware of any other carriers that might provide more choice in the investments made on behalf of our chosen charities and/or lower fees to run it? (I am in no hurry for an answer here as I recognize it is a question that may be outside your scope, or if it is more apt for CMS, I'll post it there.)
Thanks to 5i for pointing out Badger +205% which will be the next to go to the PGF before repurchase, and others I would not have acted on without 5i. Thanks again, J.
For our future contributions to a PGF are you aware of any other carriers that might provide more choice in the investments made on behalf of our chosen charities and/or lower fees to run it? (I am in no hurry for an answer here as I recognize it is a question that may be outside your scope, or if it is more apt for CMS, I'll post it there.)
Thanks to 5i for pointing out Badger +205% which will be the next to go to the PGF before repurchase, and others I would not have acted on without 5i. Thanks again, J.
Q: How long do you carry a losing stock in this case 4 in my portfolio,(CCO,POT,G,TCK). What makes you at 5i decide to sell or hold on a stock that has lost considerable value
Q: I am thinking of making adjustments to my portfolio keeping in mind the period from Dec to March is generally good for stocks and I have a one year time horizon in mind.
I have 10% exposure to emerging markets, specifically in India, and Korea where I am overweight (70%) and only in one stock –KB. I also have a position in Artis –Ax-Un that I am thinking of getting out of, with a loss. And the reasoning is thus.
With short term rates likely to rise and the tapering, there should be significant outflows from the emerging markets and the likelihood of Indian and Korean markets doing well is small. Also, the Reits here will probably underperform and the overall return could be negative despite high yields. Would you then suggest I lighten / get out of the stocks mentioned above or continue to hold and maintain diversity of my investment? I am just a little hesitant to pull the trigger specially since I am under water.
If you think I should adjust, I am considering adding on something from your model portfolio or replace with something international such as Lloyd bank, Toyota Motors or IWM –ishares Russell ETF. If you would suggest something else, that is welcome too.
I have 10% exposure to emerging markets, specifically in India, and Korea where I am overweight (70%) and only in one stock –KB. I also have a position in Artis –Ax-Un that I am thinking of getting out of, with a loss. And the reasoning is thus.
With short term rates likely to rise and the tapering, there should be significant outflows from the emerging markets and the likelihood of Indian and Korean markets doing well is small. Also, the Reits here will probably underperform and the overall return could be negative despite high yields. Would you then suggest I lighten / get out of the stocks mentioned above or continue to hold and maintain diversity of my investment? I am just a little hesitant to pull the trigger specially since I am under water.
If you think I should adjust, I am considering adding on something from your model portfolio or replace with something international such as Lloyd bank, Toyota Motors or IWM –ishares Russell ETF. If you would suggest something else, that is welcome too.
Q: This is a comment not a question about Bryon's comment.
Personally I find the question and answer portion of the service to be of huge value. Although I only post a small number of questions I do find that I benefit by reading the questions and answers posed by others. Although it may be a small number of people asking questions I think they are still adding value and I appreciate it very much. It has brought companies to my attention which I otherwise would not have discovered.
I raise this point merely to highlight that there is value beyond just getting answers to ones own questions, just something to consider when thinking about the idea of limiting the number of questions a user can pose.
Thanks for the great service, keep up the good work.
Rob
Personally I find the question and answer portion of the service to be of huge value. Although I only post a small number of questions I do find that I benefit by reading the questions and answers posed by others. Although it may be a small number of people asking questions I think they are still adding value and I appreciate it very much. It has brought companies to my attention which I otherwise would not have discovered.
I raise this point merely to highlight that there is value beyond just getting answers to ones own questions, just something to consider when thinking about the idea of limiting the number of questions a user can pose.
Thanks for the great service, keep up the good work.
Rob
Q: I have questions about earnings estimates, triggered most recently by your answer to an earlier-today question about Bird Construction. Your answer stated "The earnings estimate for Bird was $0.22 . . ."
WHO comes up with these earnings estimates and, more importantly, HOW do they come up with them? What credentials does anyone (outside the company) have to come up with such statements?
Even more importantly, why do "investors" (??) believe such estimates, to the extent that an "earnings miss" like BDT's drops the share price? Or, more correctly I guess, why does the belief in what would seem to be flimsy evidence like an estimate drive up the share price?
But I'm willing to be educated (that is why I'm here<g>).
WHO comes up with these earnings estimates and, more importantly, HOW do they come up with them? What credentials does anyone (outside the company) have to come up with such statements?
Even more importantly, why do "investors" (??) believe such estimates, to the extent that an "earnings miss" like BDT's drops the share price? Or, more correctly I guess, why does the belief in what would seem to be flimsy evidence like an estimate drive up the share price?
But I'm willing to be educated (that is why I'm here<g>).
Q: I support comment by Bryon. Further more most of the questions asked by members already have a recent or prior satisfactory answers in the Q & A section of the website. I suggest members should search first before asking.
Q: I have a comment rather than a question.
From the chorus of gratitude expressed, you can tell how valued 5i service is. I certainly join the choir and I particularly value this question/answer section. Ironically that is my source of concern.
My concern is that the volume of questions is becoming so high that you will be forced to suspend this part of the service. I would find that a major loss.
I would hope that if volume is becoming a problem, you would consider other approaches rather than suspending the section. I would consider eliminating questions on the US, restricting the number of companies per question to one and/or restricting the number of questions one individual may ask.
I would love the question section to continue as it is but if any problem develops I would certainly prefer restrictions to losing it completely.
Bryon in Elmira
From the chorus of gratitude expressed, you can tell how valued 5i service is. I certainly join the choir and I particularly value this question/answer section. Ironically that is my source of concern.
My concern is that the volume of questions is becoming so high that you will be forced to suspend this part of the service. I would find that a major loss.
I would hope that if volume is becoming a problem, you would consider other approaches rather than suspending the section. I would consider eliminating questions on the US, restricting the number of companies per question to one and/or restricting the number of questions one individual may ask.
I would love the question section to continue as it is but if any problem develops I would certainly prefer restrictions to losing it completely.
Bryon in Elmira
Q: I currently hold only 6 companies in my TFSA. T.TO, TOG.TO, RFC.V, CSU.TO, STN.TO and BEP-UN.TO. I want to sell off a portion of my gains from this year and also add a bit more capital to add two or three more stocks to this portfolio. My goal is to eventually have 10 good stocks to manage in this portfolio. Do you have any suggestions of stocks to add that would both add diversity and growth potential?
Thanks
Thanks
Q: Hi Peter&gang,just want to tell you that your membership fee of$87was the best investment I've ever made.Took a small portion out of my investment account($50000),set up another margin acct.,then using my margin set up a full model portfolio except for G,just can't pull the trigger on that one yet,I'm up 35% on my $50000 so far.My question is,some of these stocks are getting to look a little expensive,yet none have been replaced with another equity which may have a bigger upside.Do you think you will be making any changes soon?Not complaining,just asking,keep up the good work.
Q: My mother in law a recent widow and has no investment experience wants to invest the total amounts she has (Cash $400 K, TFSA $62K and a RIF of $285K) into Harris Bond Funds.
She going to be 80. Her monthly income consists of CPP, OAS (for now may be clawed back next year) and 2 indexed pensions hers (that is small) and his which is $2,300.00 per month and a RIF.
I can not see the point of paying the Investment Management fees to do this, where an ETF can get you the same thing.
I would like to see her invest in the model port.
Do you see a problem in my thinking?
Thanks for your time
Mike
She going to be 80. Her monthly income consists of CPP, OAS (for now may be clawed back next year) and 2 indexed pensions hers (that is small) and his which is $2,300.00 per month and a RIF.
I can not see the point of paying the Investment Management fees to do this, where an ETF can get you the same thing.
I would like to see her invest in the model port.
Do you see a problem in my thinking?
Thanks for your time
Mike
Q: Not so much a question as a note about forum etiquette, using LARGE CAPS to pose a question is like shouting at somebody, and nobody really needs to shout.
Q: i have lost in 15 years out of 20 and was about to give up but thanks to you and your team hope cameback.Why should i buy B when A ARE DOING BETTER AND SAFFER.i mean csu,cgx,stn,esl,bns?.
Q: Hello Peter and 5i Team
My question is regarding my wife's RRSP room which currently is at approx $20,000. She has an indexed pension and anticipates retiring in about 10 years. In addition she has approx $60,000 in her RRSP which she has chosen to be in low risk investments. When she retires she will also receive her sick time payout of 6 months salary($55,000 in today's dollars)
We have been forgoing contributing further to her RRSP with the idea of rolling the sick time payout directly into her RRSP to avoid the tax hit. Anticipating that she can add another $20,000-$30,000 in RRSP room in the next 10 years is this a wise move? To totally top up her RRSP now would require borrowed money.
Thank You
My question is regarding my wife's RRSP room which currently is at approx $20,000. She has an indexed pension and anticipates retiring in about 10 years. In addition she has approx $60,000 in her RRSP which she has chosen to be in low risk investments. When she retires she will also receive her sick time payout of 6 months salary($55,000 in today's dollars)
We have been forgoing contributing further to her RRSP with the idea of rolling the sick time payout directly into her RRSP to avoid the tax hit. Anticipating that she can add another $20,000-$30,000 in RRSP room in the next 10 years is this a wise move? To totally top up her RRSP now would require borrowed money.
Thank You