Investment Q&A

Q: Hello All,

I am confused by the. Continued weakness of Argonaut Gold (AR) and was attempting to understand the relative valuation. How does AR compare to a company like BTO? Are the relatively the same size companies? Do they 'deserve' to have comparable share prices? Would it be fair to expect AR to fall to the $3.00 range? Finally, which company would you consider to be a stronger buy and hold prospect?

Thank you for your help!

DON

Q: Any furth comments on Lucara Diamond LUC. Las comment was in February. Is it still a buy at 1.90?

Q: Peter VALE SA on New York. Thoughts on the miner - is trading below 200 day and near 52 week low. Pays a nice dividend and I am a patient value investor - with fewer names to choose from these days.

Q: I have held S (2% weighting) for just over 2 years and am finally back to par. I do not need to raise cash and it is my only holding in the materials sector outside of gold. My portfolio is weighted towards income (71 years old). Would you sell here and what would be a good replacement?

Thanks Team

Q: Hi Peter & 5i Team,

In your answer to Marc on April 16 regarding Kirkland Lake Gold (KGI), you wrote "The company ... and is probably worried about getting taken over ala Osisko."

Can you explain why a company would be "worried about getting taken over"? I thought that is a good thing to happen (atleast for shareholders who earn a premium on the takeover). Is it not also beneficial for the management of the company?

Thanks in advance.
Francis

Q: Hello 5i,on the most recent offer by Yamana and Agnico for Osisko could you comment as to your opinion as to if this is the last offer would you hold onto Osisko and take the shares of Yamana and Agnico or sell into the market? Also say on the basis of if you hold 1000 shares as of now of Osisko what would be the break down as to how many shares and or cash would you receive of Yamana and Agnico and when would this deal be completed.
Thanks Michael

Q: Peter and Team,

Is it time to cut and run on Kirkland Lake Gold? It feels wrong to sell such a high grade asset so low but it seems like it can't do anything right these days. Maybe I should be selling this and rolling it into my existing B2 Gold position (also own Goldcord and some bullion) or maybe I should be moving it to another "physical" name totally out of the gold space like Stella Jones?

I can't help but feel like the day I sell KGI will be the day that I miss out on some big guy coming in and buying this at a premium but still cheap!

Q: Hello 5i.
I have been sitting back and watching the developments in the takeover attempt on Augusta AZC by HudBay as per your advice from my previous question. Augusta has since claimed there are multiple parties interested in purchasing the company. HudBay seems to be calling their bluff and is trying to get the Canadian regulators to remove the shareholder rights plan so they can get on with things. If there are other interested parties should they have showed their cards by now? Would it be prudent to still sit and see what develops or is the challenge to rights plan the signal to head for the exit? I would like to be gone with almost my original investment if there is nobody coming but HudBay at the end of it all as they have stated their plan is to wear them down over time as they have done to others previously. Thanks for all your help.

Dave

Q: Your thoughts on Sherrit please.

Q: Hi Peter, a couple of days ago I asked for your advice in this space on SWY after its massive financing for Renard diamond project in Northern Quebec, I am holding the shares since 2010 and experienced all the ups and downs also reverse splits and averaging down I am finally in black, is it wise to hold on to this company's shares till production start in 1st quarter of 2016 or take some profits now ?
Your comment is greatly appreciated.
Thank you. M.N

Q: Hi, I would like your views on Centerra Gold generally and in terms of value. Also, do you think the dividend is relatively safe? I am looking for a small exposure to the gold sector. Would you have another name that you would recomend instead, which pays a dividend. Thanks for your input.

Q: Re NA palladium. The price has tanked because of poor results recent financing and dilution of stock. However I have read that because of recent Russia. Ukraine problems the demand for production here and anticipated commodity price increase this could be an attractive speculation. Your comment?
Stock symbol pal. ( seems to show as pdl in some places)

Q: I am thinking of investing in Goldcorp. Are there any concerns due to the ongoing and well published battle over Osisko. i.e. negative impact to stock price if hostile to bid fails.

Thanks

Phil

Q: I can find very little about ELR which is now trading at $.075. Is it still a viable company? Thanks

Q: In regards to my question on amerigo arg I was under the impression that the dividend was eliminated a while back, TD Waterhouse doesn't show a dividend or yield for this security.

Q: Can I get your thoughts on amerigo arg, I've held it for some time and I'm down about 15%. Is it worth keeping or should I sell and move on.

Q: Hi 5i, my question is regarding the LME (London Metal Exchange). i have read and listened to various guests on BNN saying a "shake up" on the LME will happen this year. what i find confusing is the opinions have a high degree of discrepancy. some are of the opine that the change won't be noticed, some say a flash crash could occur with regards to metal prices. so i would like your opinion on this topic and how should a non-ferrous metals investor deal with the possible outcome.
and secondly , does a free site exist that has charts available to illustrate volumes of a particular stock on a daily basis ? thanx norm

Q: can you give any further comments on RBI ?
I am willing to be a long term investor in this.

Robert

Q: Hi Peter & 5i: The market appears to be punishing Argonaut (AR), for its most recently reported results, with new 52-week lows. The other gold companies that I view as potential holdings are all up substantially from their lows and gold is up over $100 an ounce from its bottom (though all have retreated some from their most recent peaks). I’m very light on golds and looking to start taking my weighting up with a basket of 4 or 5 holdings. What do you think of adding some AR at the current level? Thanks.

Q: What is the OSK shares worth based on the YRI offer? What are the odds of Goldcorp offering a higher bid? Thanks