- iShares Diversified Monthly Income ETF (XTR)
- Fidelity Monthly Income Class Series S5 (FID418)
- TD Tactical Monthly Income Fund - Investor Series (TDB2580)
Appreciate your insight.
Paul F.
TDB2580 has an MER of 2.04%. It is a tactical balanced monthly income fund, with 33% fixed income exposure and the rest equities. It is approx. half US and half Canada. It has a 4-star Morningstar rating and 1st quartile 10-year returns of 6.15%. For a mutual fund, it has done well enough. XTR would be a similar ETF, but XTR does have lower five year performance by about one percentage point. We would be OK keeping the fund. FID418 MER is 2.08%. 10-year is 4.76%. It is 31% fixed income, and equities are 33% foreign. Indicated yield is 4.18%. With its performance being closer to XTR, we would be fine swapping it. Note XTR has a higher percentage of fixed income than either fund, so is a bit more conservative overall.