5i Filter - Below Book Value

Ryan M Jul 07, 2014

The focus of the July filter is to present some stocks that do not get as much attention at 5i Research. We typically do not like stocks trading below book value because it usually means that there is something wrong at or with the company’s prospects. It may be in the form of declining revenues, overvalued assets or even some sort of pending asset write-down or dividend cut that could lead to a stock trading below its book value. There are also times when a company may not be given the full credit it deserves, providing opportunity for excess returns. This filter looks at companies trading at a price to book ratio below one that pay a dividend while also having positive earnings. The dividend and positive earnings are an attempt to filter out the companies that are destroying value through consistent losses or that are not generating any revenues. It is important to remember that this is only the output of a filter and not any sort of endorsement of the companies:

 JulyFilter

As one might expect, REITs dominate the list as valuations have remained depressed with fears of changes in interest rates affecting the prospects of these companies. There are also a few names trading at very low P/B ratios and very high yields. While these often look attractive, we would tend to avoid these names in the high majority of cases as both the low P/B and high yield act as red flags from the market. Investors that ignore these red flags that the market provides, do so at their own risk.

12 comments

Comments

Login to post a comment.

R
Ryan
Jul 15, 2014
Thanks Gordon.
Noel, we will take a look at doing a filter with dividend increases for the next one.
Jeff, sometimes different services will return different results. You could also be looking at historical book value while this filter looks at forward estimates. NAV and book value for REITs can be different. We will try to do a blog on the differences in the future.
G
Gordon
Jul 11, 2014

Hi Ryan
Really like how you break down all the ratios and give actual meaning to them when trying to analyze and compare companies.
N
Noel
Jul 9, 2014
This idea of sharing some stock screening results is great. I would appreciate one of stocks that have increased their dividend by a certain percentage (say 10% per year or more for 5 consecutive years) that also meet other criteria you folks see fit to use.
J
Jeff
Jul 8, 2014
Hi Ryan, I like the idea of looking at stock groups through different paradigms but I am surprised that even more REITs and REOCs did not turn up on this month's list, making me wonder what parameters were used for the screen. For example the Morguard parent -MRC- has a book value of $185 (per TDW) trades at $143 for a P/BPS of 0.77 and also has a larger market cap than the two affiliates that made the list. Ditto for TN.UN - Book $9.57 - trade $8.19 - P/BPS of 0.85. I could probably go on but I just researched the ones in my P/F.

What confuses me about REITs in particular is how analysts seem to use Book Value and Net Asset Value interchangeably yet I turn up different ratios for some REITs depending on which measure is being used. Perhaps you could address this one point specifically.
R
Ryan
Jul 8, 2014
HI Paul, the intention of a filter is mainly to generate potential investment ideas. It is not supposed to give you every company detail from which an investment decision is made. We looked at certain factors that may be of interest to a certain investment style. The investor is then responsible to dig deeper and determine if any of the companies on the list meet their personal requirements. A fine balance also needs to be struck when choosing a filter because if you have too many filter items, you will get too few results or too many results if the filter has too few factors being filtered.
P
Paul
Jul 7, 2014
I am not sure how this helps the small investor.

It does not mention EPS over the last 5 or 10 years Nor does it mention anything about Revenue Growth To me it is a short term snapshot. It also does not mention whether the company is earning enough to cover its dividend

We all want companies that have the potential for dividend increases From this report it would be difficult for me to figure this out

Sorry to be negative because 5i is a fabulous tool for the small investor but if you could redo the report using different filters it may be more helpful
R
Ryan
Jul 7, 2014
Thanks everyone, it was an uploading issue. Should be fixed now.
S
Scot
Jul 7, 2014
Whatever you did Ryan fixed the problem. Thanks

Scot
D
Dale
Jul 7, 2014
same problem and recently had a tech guy go over computer and update everything
A
Andrzej
Jul 7, 2014
Hello Ryan,
I have the same problem as Scot and I'm using Mozilla Firefox. All text of your Filter article is visible but there is but there is empty space (blank) below no list or table of the companies filtered by 5i Research.

Andrew B.
K
Ken
Jul 7, 2014
I have the same problem as Scot with internet explorer. It could be my security settings I suppose.
S
Scot
Jul 7, 2014
Ryan,
Maybe you could check your upload of the stock list as all I see is a BLANK (white) box with nothing in it?? (using Crome as a browser). All the text of the Blog is visable both above and below the empty box.

Scot